Thanksgiving Would You Rather: A Free Printable Game for the Entire Family

When the Thanksgiving season rolls around, we look forward to turkey, mashed potatoes, pie, and gathering around the table with the people we love most. But in between the food prep, football games, and cleanup, we’ve found that it’s fun to sprinkle in some laughter and lighthearted games. That’s why we created this Thanksgiving Would You Rather printable game—a silly, family-friendly set of questions that gets everyone talking, laughing, and connecting.

Whether you’re celebrating with your entire family, a group of close friends, or even planning an activity for the classroom, this fun Thanksgiving game is a perfect way to add a playful touch to your gathering.

Printable Thanksgiving Would You Rather game on a blue background

Need a fun game to play around your Thanksgiving table? Our Thanksgiving Would You Rather Free Printable Game will have everyone laughing. And it may have you questioning other’s choices.

Would you rather have a whole gravy boat or a gallon of cranberry sauce?

Would you rather do dishes with corn stuck on everything or make the entire thanksgiving meal?

Would you rather eat turkey for life, or stuffing?

Would you rather be a pilgrim or live in the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade?

Would you rather eat mashed potatoes for the rest of your life or have neverending thanksgiving leftovers?

Would you rather live in the white house wearing a pilgrim hat at all times or have to eat a whole turkey without utensils?

Would you rather eat an entire turkey by yourself, or eat ice cream with raw cranberries and spices?

Thse are the type of would you rather questions that make for some fun conversations.

If you are ready to add some laughs to your Thanksgiving dinner this Would You Rather Game will do just that. Print this off and hand it out to everyone around the table. Try to keep it quiet as to what you would rather do then add in the laughs when everyone explains their answers.

This game is perfect for kids and adults, the whole family can play this. You could print it out and play while watching the thanksgiving parade, after your family turkey trot, place it on the kid table, play after you finish dessert (a slice of pie), or while eating your favorite dish.

So right before you head to take that nap at your relative’s house, go black friday shopping, or watch your favorite Christmas movie, make sure you spend some time laughing with your friends and family.

Why Play Thanksgiving Would You Rather?

Thanksgiving gatherings are special, but sometimes, between food and football, conversations can get stuck in the same loop: “How’s work?” “How’s school?” “Did you try the stuffing?”

That’s where this Thanksgiving printable game comes in. Here’s why it’s such a hit:

It’s for the entire family. Everyone from young kids to grandparents can join in. The questions are family-friendly, silly, and easy to answer.
It sparks conversations. You’ll learn quirky things about your siblings, parents, or friends that you never knew.
It breaks the ice. If you’re hosting close friends or extended relatives who don’t know each other well, this is a fun way to get people laughing together.
It’s simple and free. All you need to do is print the cards, cut them out, and play. No special supplies, no long prep, and no stress.
It’s versatile. You can play around the dinner table, during pie, at a Friendsgiving, or even as a classroom activity the week before break.

Here’s what you’ll need for your own Thanksgiving Would You Rather Free Printable Game:

This post contains affiliate links.

Thanksgiving Would You Rather Free Printable Game found at the bottom of this post. Just click on the “Download Here” box.
Printer – this is the one I have and really like.
Paper
Pencils

Directions for Thanksgiving Would You Rather Free Printable Game:

Step 1:

Download and Print the game cards. We recommend printing on cardstock for durability, but regular paper works too.

Step 2:

Give each player a copy of the free printable game, along with a pencil.

Would You Rather Thanksgiving Free Printable game on a blue background with preferences circled

Step 3:

Start each line with “Would you rather…” and circle your answer. After everyone is finished, read trough them as a group. You’ll find that everyone has different ideas of what is preferable in each situation. Some of their ideas are down right funny.

Where to Use This Fun Thanksgiving Game

One of the best parts about this activity is how versatile it is. It is full of funny Thanksgiving questions. Here are some ways you can use it this Thanksgiving season:

1. Around the Dinner Table

Print a stack of cards and place one at each seat. As the meal winds down, go around the table and let each person ask their question. It’s a playful way to keep the conversation flowing, especially during a long Thanksgiving dinner. Or with your apple pie.

2. Friendsgiving Gatherings

If you’re celebrating with close friends, this game makes a great icebreaker. Play while you’re waiting for dishes to finish baking or after dessert when everyone’s relaxing.

3. Classroom Fun

Teachers love this activity as a no-prep way to get students talking. Print the cards, divide kids into groups, and let them quiz each other. It’s also a great “brain break” activity before the holiday break.

4. Family Nights

Use it as part of your fun Thanksgiving activities leading up to the big day. Pull out the cards during a family dinner in November to start some silly conversations.

5. Virtual Gatherings

If your entire family can’t be together in person, hop on a video call and play virtually. One person can read the questions aloud, and everyone can shout out their answers.

Tips for Making the Game Extra Fun

Mix up the groups. Pair younger cousins with grandparents to get some hilarious responses.
Keep score (optional). Some families like to tally answers and see which choices were most popular.
Add props. Hand out mini pumpkins, pilgrim hats, or turkey stickers as playful tokens when someone answers.
Play in rounds. If you have a big group, break into smaller groups so everyone has more chances to answer.

Why This Is the Perfect Thanksgiving Game

Every year, families look for ways to keep kids entertained and adults engaged while waiting for the turkey to roast. That’s why this Thanksgiving printable game has become a favorite.

It’s silly enough for kids, yet clever enough to make adults laugh too. And because it’s printable, it doesn’t require complicated prep or expensive supplies. Just download, print, cut, and play.

The best part? It becomes a tradition. Families often tell us that once they try it, they add it to their list of fun Thanksgiving activities to play year after year.

Bringing Gratitude into the Game

While this game is lighthearted, it also naturally sparks reflection. As people answer questions like “Would you rather have turkey or sides?” it leads to conversations about family traditions, favorite recipes, and happy memories. It’s a gentle way to mix in gratitude and thankfulness without making it feel like a chore.

Pair it with a gratitude activity, like going around the table and sharing what you’re thankful for this year. Together, these activities create a beautiful balance of silliness and meaning.

To Download your free copy of our Thanksgiving Would You Rather Game, just click on the box below.

The file will open a new browser window on your computer. If you have pop-ups blocked this may be an issue. You can save to your computer and will most likely go into your download file. This is a PDF file and should print easily for you.

Please remember all printables are property of The Crafting Chicks, LLP and are for personal, non-commercial use only. Please do not sell, or alter in anyway. If linking to this post, please provide credit.

So instead of just sitting around this thanksgiving weekend trying not to eat an entire pumpkin pie, print off some of our fun free printable games and really get to know your immediate family members.

Don’t worry though, not all the questions are about thanksgiving food. 😉 There are prompts about all sorts of things. Questions that will even make the adult table and the whole extended family chuckle.

Like:

Would you rather sing the national anthem at an NFL football game or host your first thanksgiving in a turkey costume?

Or would you rather sit on the couch with a live turkey watching thanksgiving football, or eat thanksgiving dessert in a cranberry bog?

Would you rather use only a microwave to cook your favorite thanksgiving dish or give turkey feathers as christmas presents to everyone in New York City?

Would you rather eat your own turkey in a bathtub, or have to eat pumpkin pies while watching a Charlie Brown Thanksgiving school play?

Final Thoughts

The Thanksgiving Would You Rather game is more than just a deck of silly questions—it’s a perfect game for bringing people together, breaking the ice, and sparking laughter during one of the most cherished holidays of the year.

Whether you’re playing with your entire family, a group of close friends, or a classroom full of students, this printable will quickly become one of your favorite traditions.

So this Thanksgiving Day, as you gather around the turkey and pumpkin pie, don’t forget to carve out a little time for fun. Grab your Thanksgiving printable game, hand out the cards, and enjoy the giggles and smiles that follow.

Because at the end of the day, Thanksgiving is about more than just food—it’s about creating memories, sharing joy, and celebrating togetherness. And this game is the perfect way to do just that.

✨ Download your free Thanksgiving Would You Rather printable game today and get ready to laugh with the people you love most!